Zum Hauptinhalt springen
Logo Diversity & Inclusion Platform, zur Startseite

Mental Health at Work: From Individual Resilience to Systemic Responsibility

Dieser Beitrag ist auch in Deutsch verfügbar.

Imagine an employee experiencing symptoms of depression. They want to continue working, but their usual workload has become increasingly difficult to manage.

What should their organisation do?

The familiar response might be to recommend time off, professional help, or resilience training. These measures can be valuable. But they leave an important question unanswered: What happens when the employee returns from time off to exactly the same workload, expectations, and working conditions? For many employees, this is not simply a question of wellbeing, but of whether they can remain in employment.

This is more than a hypothetical concern. According to the World Health Organization, more than one billion people worldwide live with a mental health condition.1 An international analysis of population surveys estimates that approximately half of the population will experience at least one mental health disorder by the age of 75.2

In Switzerland, mental illness accounted for 53% of disability pensions in December 2025 and was the main cause of disability for 55% of people receiving vocational integration measures in 2025. It was also the leading cause of new disability pensions, particularly among young adults aged 18 to 24.3

Mental health is therefore not a marginal workplace concern. It is central to whether people can enter, remain in, and participate sustainably in working life.

What if we changed the work, not just the person?

Mental health is often discussed as a personal matter. When someone struggles, we tend to focus on what that person can do to cope. A more systemic approach considers how work itself can be adapted. This might involve changing responsibilities, adjusting workloads, introducing flexibility, or making support easier to access.

One way of doing this is through what researchers call idiosyncratic deals, or i-deals: individually negotiated work arrangements tailored to employees' particular needs.4 These adjustments can take three main forms:

  1. Schedule i-deals: flexibility over when work is done, allowing employees to manage medical appointments, recovery, or fluctuating symptoms.
  2. Location i-deals: flexibility over where work is done, potentially reducing commuting demands or providing a more suitable working environment, although working remotely may also increase isolation.
  3. Task i-deals: adjustments to the work itself, such as changes to responsibilities, workload, cognitive demands, or role design.

Previous research suggests that such arrangements are associated with lower intentions to leave an organisation, partly because they strengthen employees' perceived ability to work.5 Yet an important question remains: Are all types of adjustments equally helpful, or do some matter more than others?

What helps people stay in their jobs?

To investigate this, researchers at the Competence Centre for Diversity, Disability and Inclusion (CCDI) at the University of St.Gallen followed employees with diagnosed mental health conditions who had been referred to an early intervention programme within the Swiss social insurance system.

By combining information from employees, supervisors, a close family member or friend, and medical and employment records, they examined how different workplace adjustments were associated with job retention.

Not all workplace adjustments make the same difference

The findings revealed an important pattern. Both task and schedule i-deals were associated with a greater likelihood of remaining employed.

When researchers compared the relative importance of the three types of adjustments in explaining job retention, task i-deals made the largest contribution (46.7%), followed by schedule i-deals (37.4%) and location i-deals (15.9%).

In practical terms, changing what someone is expected to do, or how their responsibilities are structured, may help reduce the demands of work and make continued employment more manageable. Schedule flexibility may serve a different purpose. It can create space for recovery, medical appointments, or periods when symptoms fluctuate.

Location flexibility, meanwhile, showed no consistent benefit in this study. Working from home, for example, may reduce commuting demands and distractions for one person, while increasing isolation or blurring work-life boundaries for another. The lesson is that support needs to match the difficulty a person is experiencing.

An inclusive workplace is not one in which everyone is treated identically. It is one in which people can access what they need to perform sustainably.

The person who can make the difference

Workplace adjustments rarely happen on their own. Someone needs to recognise the need, start a conversation, and help make the adjustment possible. But whose support matters most?

For employees with diagnosed mental health conditions, the findings pointed to a particularly important source of support: their direct supervisor. Supervisor support accounted for the largest share of the relative explanatory contribution of the three support sources (47.5%), followed by HR support (36.5%) and support from colleagues (16.0%).6

An employee may have access to an excellent organisational wellbeing programme. But if their direct manager cannot respond constructively to a disclosure or adjust an overwhelming workload, that programme may offer limited practical help.

Resilience needs a system

None of this means that managers should diagnose mental health conditions. Managers are not therapists, and they should not be expected to act as therapists. But they can help create conditions in which employees can communicate their needs safely, receive reasonable support, and continue contributing at work wherever possible.

In her recent article on Healthy Leadership, my colleague Dr. Louisa Riess explained how leaders can strengthen their own mental health and that of their teams. Building on that perspective, the next question is what organisations can do to make mental health support part of everyday working practices rather than an exceptional response to a crisis.

In the traditional approach, intervention often starts only after distress has already led to impaired functioning, absence or disengagement:

Distress → Absence → Diagnosis → HR → Intervention

By the time support begins, an employee may already be struggling to remain employed. A more systemic and preventive approach starts much earlier:

Healthy job design → Manager awareness → Early detection → Conversation → Adjustments → Accessible support → Continued participation

Return to our employee from the beginning. Instead of waiting until repeated absences trigger a formal intervention, a supportive manager might initiate a confidential conversation about workload and working conditions. Together, they could identify practical adjustments, such as changing task priorities or introducing more flexible working hours, while respecting the employee's privacy and autonomy. The goal is not to manage the person's mental health condition. It is to remove unnecessary barriers to doing their job.

For this to work consistently, organisations need more than supportive managers. They need clear procedures for requesting adjustments, managers equipped to respond appropriately, and accessible support that does not depend on employees reaching a crisis point.

Conclusion

Personal resilience matters. But if the system repeatedly creates or amplifies strain, resilience alone is not enough. Strong support systems need to work alongside personal resilience, with a focus on prevention, early engagement, continuity of care and sustained participation.

This calls for a shift in the question organisations ask:

From “How can we make employees more resilient?” to “What conditions help people remain well, recover, and stay connected to work?”

Get involved!

Building on this research, the CCDI-HSG is launching a national research initiative to identify evidence-based ways to improve the wellbeing, retention and successful completion of apprenticeships in Switzerland. Companies interested in becoming founding partners are welcome to get in touch with Dr. Mahshid Khademi (mahshid.khademi@unisg.ch).

Want to take the next step?

If you would like to put these insights into practice, our Healthy Leadership workshop helps managers recognise early signs of strain and respond constructively, while our Team Job Crafting workshop supports leaders and their teams in jointly shaping work around individual strengths and needs.


References

1 World Health Organization (2025). World mental health today: latest data. Geneva: WHO.

2 McGrath, J. J., Al-Hamzawi, A., Alonso, J., Altwaijri, Y., Andrade, L. H., Bromet, E. J., ... & Zaslavsky, A. M. (2023). Age of onset and cumulative risk of mental disorders: a cross-national analysis of population surveys from 29 countries. The Lancet Psychiatry, 10(9), 668-681.

3 Federal Social Insurance Office (BSV/FSIO) (2026). IV-Statistik 2025 [Disability insurance statistics 2025]. Bern: BSV.

4 Rousseau, D. M. (2001). Flexibility versus fairness? Organizational Dynamics, 29(4), 260–273; Rosen, C. C., Slater, D. J., Chang, C.-H., & Johnson, R. E. (2013). Let’s make a deal: Development and validation of the ex post i-deals scale. Journal of Management, 39(3), 709–742.

5 Brzykcy, A. Z., Boehm, S. A., & Baldridge, D. C. (2019). Fostering sustainable careers across the lifespan: The role of disability, idiosyncratic deals and perceived work ability. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 112, 185–198.

6 Khademi, M. & Boehm, S. A.  (2026, September 24-26). Tailored support: impact of idiosyncratic deals on the career outcomes of employees with mental health impairments. EWOP Small Group Meeting 2026: Fair and inclusive workplaces in times of changing societal climates, Lausanne, Switzerland.

Beitrag teilen

Das könnte Sie interessieren

Gesunde Führung Workshop

In einer dynamischen Arbeitswelt müssen Führungskräfte die langfristige Arbeitsfähigkeit ihrer Mitarbeitenden gezielt fördern. Gesunde Führung bedeutet, Belastungen frühzeitig zu erkennen, präventiv zu handeln und eine wertschätzende, resiliente Arbeitskultur zu schaffen. Unsere Trainings geben Impulse für Führungskräfte durch klare Kommunikation, gezielte Unterstützung und den bewussten Umgang mit Ressourcen nachhaltige Leistungsfähigkeit und langfristige Motivation zu sichern.

Team Job Crafting. Recognising potential, jointly shaping team goals

Designing work tasks and job profiles based on individual strengths is essential to make the best use of employees' capabilities. However, in the day-to-day work it is often not possible to fully implement this approach for every team member at all times. Our team job crafting workshop is designed to support leaders and their teams to jointly identify and actively shape as much crafting potential as possible.

Ähnliche Beiträge